An fMRI study of initiation and inhibition of manual and spoken responses in people who stutter

Abstract Stuttering is characterised by difficulties initiating speech and frequent interruptions to the flow of speech. Neuroimaging studies of speech production in people who stutter consistently reveal greater activity of the right inferior frontal cortex, an area robustly implicated in stopping manual and spoken responses. This has been linked to an “overactive response suppression mechanism” in people who stutter. Here, we used fMRI to investigate neural differences related to response initiation and inhibition in people who stutter and matched controls (aged 19-45) during performance of the stop-signal task in both the manual and speech domains. We hypothesised there would be increased activity in an inhibitory network centred on right inferior frontal cortex. Out of scanner behavioural testing revealed that people who stutter were slower than controls to respond to ‘go’ stimuli in both the manual and the speech domains, but the groups did not differ in their stop-signal reaction times in either domain. During the fMRI task, both groups activated the expected networks for the manual and speech tasks. Contrary to our hypothesis, we did not observe differences in task-evoked activity between people who stutter and controls during either ‘go’ or ‘stop’ trials. Targeted region-of-interest analyses in the inferior frontal cortex, the supplementary motor area and the putamen bilaterally confirmed that there were no group differences in activity. These results focus on tasks involving button presses and production of single nonwords, and therefore do not preclude inhibitory involvement related specifically to stuttering events. Our findings indicate that people who stutter do not show behavioural or neural differences in response inhibition, when making simple manual responses and producing fluent speech, contrary to predictions from the global inhibition hypothesis.